Contact ChemPoint's Customer Service Center425.378.8694
Talk to an Expert

Case Study - Vacuum Pump Failure

Case Study - Vacuum Pump Failure

Vacuum pumps are critical in the chemical manufacturing industry, and having one periodically fail can be a real problem. Read through the case study from the DuPont MOLYKOTE® Team and how they helped solve an issue with their vacuum pump failing on a monthly basis.

Molykote® Synthetic Oil Helps Solve Vacuum Pump Failure


In Midland, Michigan, a chemical manufacturing company had installed a new rotary vane vacuum pump in one of their processing buildings. This vacuum pump was to draw process gasses out of a reactor vessel. Utilizing conventional mineral oil specified in the original equipment manual (OEM) over the course of nine months, the vacuum pump would experience catastrophic failure every four to six weeks.

Lisa Honaman, a building engineer at the time, stated, “There was so much corrosion that it caused the casing to pit, and we couldn’t just make repairs.” When the vacuum pump would fail, the company would have to purchase new casings and other major components. The cost of labor and components would cost the company close to $9,000, and over a nine-month time frame, the vacuum pump failure had cost the company close to $90,000 in repairs. This vacuum pump was just one of three that were experiencing similar issues. 

Rotary Vacuum Pump and its Problem


The vacuum pumps that were installed drew hydrochloric acid (HCl) vapors from a reactor vessel that was used to manufacture chemical intermediate products. During the process, some of the acidic vapors would condense from a gas to a liquid and then mix with the oil inside the vacuum chamber. The anti-wear additives in the conventional oil mixed with the HCl vapors, causing a reaction to take place once the oil and HCl vapor came into contact with the process gas in the chamber. This reaction produced small solid particles that deposited onto the casing, which then caused pitting in the casing. Because of the pitting happening in the chamber, the corrosion from the products would then react with the hydrochloric acid, resulting in the formation of corrosive ferric acid.

“The results were devastating,” Honaman said. The pitting and the ferric chloride particles were corroding the vane tips and the walls of the vacuum pump chamber, ultimately reducing the capacity of the vacuum chamber. The buildup of imperfections from the pitting and the ferric chloride particles prevented the formation of a reliable oil film needed for a vacuum seal while also preventing surface contact, frictional wear and tear, and heat generation between the vanes’ tips and the wall of the vacuum pump.
 
In addition to the pitting, the interaction between the oil and process chemicals led to sludge forming within the vacuum pump. The rotor vanes of the pump, comprised primarily of phenolic and fiber, started breaking down due to the mixture of the sludge, corrosion, and abrasion material. This expedited the vacuum pump failure.  As the rotor turned, particles were continuously chipped off the trailing edge of the vanes, which ultimately damaged the subsequent vanes. All this cascaded and compounded the damage, which resulted in increased friction, vacuum leaks, pitting, and overheating, causing a total vane breakdown, extensive case wall damage, and overall catastrophic failure of the pump. With the pump failing, a replacement would have to be implemented, costing the company thousands of dollars in maintenance costs and system downtime. 

Solving the Problem with MOLYKOTE®


To address the consistent vacuum pump failures, MOLYKOTE® support staff believed that a specially formulated lubricant would provide better performance. The support staff faced major issues: reducing or eliminating the effects caused by the reaction between the additives in the oil and chemical process gases, and the corrosion and abrasions occurring on the metal vacuum components. The solution the MOLYKOTE® team came up with was a synthetic oil that was specially formulated for the harsh environments in which the vacuum pump was operating. This new synthetic oil was a new line of industrial lubricants, with MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil being the recommended lubricant for this specific job. 

MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil: The Solution


 
MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil is a polyalphaolefin (PAO) based oil fortified with specially selected additives. It minimizes the occurrence of additives and base oils reacting with hard process gases. The additive package incorporated in the formulation of the MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil allows the oil to reduce corrosion and sludge formation caused by the vacuum pump’s operating conditions that could result in premature lubricant breakdown and equipment failure. MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil has excellent fluid stability, even in the presence of harsh chemistries, and offers great corrosion protection in equipment such as pumps and compressors.

Traditional solvent-refined oils with zinc-based additive chemistry typically have a higher initial total acid number (TAN) value. In comparison, the MOLYKOTE® brand process gas oils are zinc free, resulting in a lower TAN value. Additionally, the base oil, which contains corrosion, rust, and oxidation preventative additives, is free of sulfur, making the oil a benign product fit for the application. The engineered MOLYKOTE® oils are also more inherently inert and resistant to oxidation and emulsification, increasing the longevity of the lubricant.

Traditional solvent-refined oils with zinc-based additive chemistry typically have a higher initial total acid number (TAN) value. In comparison, the MOLYKOTE® brand process gas oils are zinc free, resulting in a lower TAN value. Additionally, the base oil, which contains corrosion, rust, and oxidation preventative additives, is free of sulfur, making the oil a benign product fit for the application. The engineered MOLYKOTE® oils are also more inherently inert and resistant to oxidation and emulsification, increasing the longevity of the lubricant.
 
After MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil

Once maintenance employees incorporated the MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil and installed larger oil pumps, the facility saw a 30% decrease in overall operating temperatures. The temperature reduction is believed to be contributed by both the introduction of the MOLYKOTE® lubricant and the installation of the larger oil pump. The major issue that was solved was the elimination of the vacuum pump failure that was caused by corrosive pitting and the interaction between the oil additive and process gas. Introducing MOLYKOTE® L-1510 Process Oil was such a success that the facility ultimately switched all their vacuum pumps to MOLYKOTE®, saving the company nearly $90,000 in maintenance costs. 

Contact Us

PHONE  425.372.9464

Hi, let us know if you have any product questions as you visit our website.

ChemPoint reps are here to assist you